Learning Complex Causal Structures
نویسندگان
چکیده
Most current theories of human causal learning are essentially parameter estimators: they assume a fixed causal structure and estimate causal strengths within that structure. In these theories, absence of causation is represented as zero causal strength, rather than a distinct causal structure. In this paper, we first present the theoretical framework of Bayesian networks, which can represent both structure (presence/absence of causation) and parameters (strength of causation). We then present a series of experiments involving a particularly complex causal structure and a novel methodology that focuses on structural discriminations, rather than parameter estimation. These experiments suggest that people are capable of doing more than just parameter estimation. A significant group of participants seems to be learning (something isomorphic to) a Bayesian
منابع مشابه
Causal Structure Learning and Inference: A Selective Review
In this paper we give a review of recent causal inference methods. First, we discuss methods for causal structure learning from observational data when confounders are not present and have a close look at methods for exact identifiability. We then turn to methods which allow for a mix of observational and interventional data, where we also touch on active learning strategies. We also discuss me...
متن کاملAutomatic Discovery of Complex Causality By
This study entails the understanding of and the development of a computational method for automatically extracting complex expressions in language that correspond to event to event sequential relations in the real world. We here develop component procedures of a system that would be capable of taking raw linguistic input (such as those from narrative writings or social network data), and find r...
متن کاملLearning Causal Structure from Undersampled Time Series
Even if one can experiment on relevant factors, learning the causal structure of a dynamical system can be quite difficult if the relevant measurement processes occur at a much slower sampling rate than the “true” underlying dynamics. This problem is exacerbated if the degree of mismatch is unknown. This paper gives a formal characterization of this learning problem, and then provides two sets ...
متن کاملImproving human understanding and design of complex multi-level systems with animation and parametric relationship supports
Complex systems are challenging to design, particularly when they contain multi-level organizations with non-obvious relationships among design components. Here, we investigate engineering students’ capacity to search for optimal nanoscale biosystem designs with stochastic component and system behaviors. The study aims to characterize information types that facilitate human learning and improve...
متن کاملConnecting Causal Events: Learning Causal Structures Through Repeated Interventions Over Time
How do we learn causal structures? All current approaches use scenarios in which trials are temporally independent; however, people often learn about scenarios unfolding over time. In such cases, people may assume that other variables don’t change at the same instant as an intervention. In Experiment 1, participants were much more successful at learning causal structures when this assumption wa...
متن کامل